Use it yourself and keep improving it.
I think this is an interesting point here.
I use what I make."
If you don't use it yourself, "integrity dictates that you make an effort to have the research results put in."
Another expression
Make the deliverables available to others than yourself
Publish detailed production instructions.
Use it yourself and keep improving it.
@shokai: "I feel like this field of research (HCI) is full of twisting logic and justification for seemingly useless toys." I can't help but wonder what this is all about now.
You're not using what you've made, and you're thinking defensively at the same time when you're making up the concept.
Peer review looks for novelty and holes in the experiments and methods of argumentation.
Anything can be made useful by specifying extreme situations (HCI makes this easy thanks to the Human element).
The best tactic to create novelty easily is to make strange things that even you don't use because of these factors.
I would think that in other engineering fields, the value of the extreme situation setting itself would be sifted to some extent by market needs (such as the fact that such a network configuration is useless).
The extreme situation setting by the Human element is strong because it can be used as an invincible shield that can never be beaten if it is well-spoken, poly-colored, etc.
[* If you set up an extreme situation, I think the integrity is whether or not you are making an effort to get your research results in there.
make the results available to others than yourself, publish detailed production methods, use it yourself and keep improving it, etc., if you don't see any of these
It looks like you're toying with the Human element to make it useful.
It's just that it's not fair to act like it's convenient when you don't think it's convenient or necessary yourself.
That's all there is to it.
relevance
---
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/自分で使いまくって改良し続ける using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.